Monday, October 30, 2017

So How Do You Know If It Is True?



National and world news was of minor importance in the small Midwestern town where I grew up. Television did not arrive until I was in junior high. Its purpose was considered entertainment - not to inform people about what was happening in the country or beyond.

We did have a weekly newspaper to tell us about engagements and weddings, deaths and funerals, hog futures, and "who poured" when the ladies got together to chat about town goings-on. They knew most of what would be in the paper before it arrived!

The Saturday movie matinee had news-briefs, but we young people could care less. We had come for the feature film. What might be happening in the rest of the country or Europe had little relevance to us or our parents. After all, soldiers had come home from WWII and, after some tension with their wives, who had been in charge during their absence, they had re-asserted their position as heads of household.

If you had asked anyone if news that did filter through was true, you would be met by a puzzled stare. What do you mean by true? What motivation would any journalist have for reporting news that was not true? Of course there were editorials, but you knew up-front that an editorial was one person's opinion and that was not news. Photographic journalism adhered to a strict code of non-altered photos - no photoshop editorializing! What you saw was exactly what happened.

Today we are awash in news. Comparing television's PBS news with Fox news (or any other network) is one way to sort out opinions from reporting of actual events. There is so much news, sometimes we  feel battered by things we do  not want to hear - over and over again. Coping skills range from ignoring most of the news to reading only summaries written by trusted journalists to making the evening news a part of life's daily ritual - or ignoring the news altogether.

It is the term fake news that is troubling. Mistrust in the media is high. Some of the current President's supporters believe that anything negative about the President is automatically untrue. As if he is a perfect person with their best interests at the center of his policy-making. Equally adamant are those who believe the President consistently lies and they see no good in anything that comes out of his mouth or his Twitter.

The result: we have no public or private arena for useful discussion of critical issues.

Our great country is in serious trouble. Fake news does exist. It twists reality beyond recognition. Patterns of once buried racism, fears about people who are "different" or have another religion, bullying and violence, a desire to exclude from our country anyone who is not like us, and deep frustration with anything political - make responsible journalism difficult.

Yet there are are many good and decent people who hold doors for each other, drive responsibly, and who do not believe a gun is the solution.

We talk about opioid addiction - a very real problem. But we live with an equally worse addiction to power.  As our country was being formed, government was created with checks and balances. Today that structure is being challenged by very smart people whose first priority is "me first." 

We have survived much as a country. Even if we are weary of questioning the validity of honest journalism, technology makes it possible to give us options never before imagined. Like kids with their cell phones, we need to be wise.

In one of the books I co-authored with my husband, there is a photograph I took high in the Peruvian Andes. In the foreground of the original photo were some very mangy sheep, as only sheep can be in the spring. These sheep detracted from the photo so I photo-shopped them out. My dear husband was aghast. "you can't do that!" I said that "yes I can and I have." The point of including the photo was not that sheep were shedding their winter wool, but the vista of distant mountains and colored clothes drying on rocks in the foreground.

Was it fake news to exile these sheep? No! If we allowed everything before us to enter into our vision, we would quietly become dysfunctional and then go mad. The human capacity to screen input is an essential quality. However, moral honesty to do so is equally essential. We need to hone our honesty with great care, not generate self-serving lies and illusions. When we were in Kenya we drove along the edge of a huge slum. To have blinded ourselves to this extreme poverty or to have made ignorant remarks about why people lived this way would have been immoral.

We need that moral honesty in what we observe. Then we can bring together our different opinions and redeem our country with much needed conversations.   

Wednesday, February 1, 2017

And From What Country Did Your Ancestors Immigrate?

My heart aches for those caught in the immigration ban. You see, I am the granddaughter  of Danish immigrants. My grandmother came here as a teenager with her parents. My grandfather was in his twenties and changed his last name as he passed through Ellis Island – for what reason we will never know. And I married to someone whose German grandparents fled to this country to escape religious persecution.

It is not that my personal story is special or unique. It is the very ordinary story. Shared with many many of my friends. People who came here with next to nothing to start new lives. Hardworking people willing to leave family and friends they would never see again. All of them endured a long sea journey.

We are a country of immigrants. Even native First Nation people, who claimed this land first. People who became winners of Nobel prizes. Shopkeepers and farmers.  Composers and artists and writers. Scientists, engineers, and teachers. Refugees fleeing war. All of these people have contributed in many ways to our culture and our heritage.

The Statue of Liberty is a symbol of our American dream. At her base are these words:

"Give me your tired, your poor,
your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
the wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!"

As a child I wondered what this golden door was. But it did not matter to me. I fervently believed these words, this motto for my country. And I still do.

Now I see streams of refugees, whose lives are far worse than anything my particular ancestors endured. Some of them die in their attempts to escape from camps that give them no promise of a future.

The solutions to their plight are complex. But to bar them from hope because of their religion is cruelty beyond imagination. In this country, along with many other countries, lie compassionate solutions – not responses of bigotry and hatred.

I love my peaceful little neighborhood. I have Muslim neighbors, family from Ethiopia, and Hmong people and others. We enrich each other’s lives. All of us yearn to “breathe free” as Lady Liberty reminds us day after day.

Read individual stories of people landing here and not granted entry – to be shipped back to their home countries. The six-year old who “might be a threat.” The elderly grandfather who came to see his grandchildren – detained 17 hours and then put on a plane for the long trip back to his country. Spouses separated from spouses already here. Graduate students unable to re-enter after a visit with family back home. The list goes on and on.


Recite the words at the base of the Statue of Liberty out loud . Sing a few verses of America and other patriotic songs. Remember your own ancestry – because we are all immigrants - the daughters and sons of people who came here to build a better life for themselves and for their children.A better life for all of us.

Sunday, January 15, 2017

No More Buggy Whips

It has been said the only sure things are death and taxes. I would add a third category. Change at this time in history is a guaranteed reality!

Predicting change is another matter. It rivals crystal ball gazing in accuracy. Today change is occurring at an even faster rate. No wonder people everywhere are panicky and angry. They struggle to find political voice. Believing they then can control their future.

Where I live, we joke about weather predictions. Yes, it will snow in the winter and there will be some hot summer days. But those generalities are not too useful for planning an rain-free outdoor wedding in June or when there will be sufficient snow for cross-country skiing.

Likewise, predicting changes in the future, in terms of the employment market or technological advances, is more of an art than a science. If you can say you are paid for what you love to do, you will have a wonderful and productive life. But there if there is little or no market for what you love to do, you may end up with an unsatisfying life and mark time until retirement.

When I think of major changes occurring during my lifetime, most of them were beyond anyone’s imagination at the time. I remember the first computer I encountered. This humungous creation occupied an entire temperature and humidity-controlled room.  If you squinted your eyes, you almost could imagine approaching an ancient Greek oracle for an answer to some grave concern.

Attendants in white coats cared for this mysterious being. If a person wanted to run something on this computer, the program was handed to the attendant. Of course, the program had to be written in the computer’s language.

Today, I carry my cell phone in my pocket. When I have a question about something, the answer is immediate. Who could ever have imagined such a handy little device while standing at the doorway of that room-sized machine!

Further, my little device connects me with others all around the world. Decades ago, when I traveled out of the country, calling home was complicated and required advanced planning. Today, it doesn’t matter if I am halfway around the world -calling home only requires calculating the difference in time zones so as not to wake family or friends in the middle of the night.

When we go back in time, change occurred more slowly. Before my time, people traveled by horse and buggy. A buggy whip was an essential piece of equipment. Those buggy whips were manufactured somewhere and provided an income for some hardworking men (the women were busy keeping house and raising the children). When people begun driving the first auto-cars, buggy whips were no longer needed. And people who prided themselves with making those fine buggy whips found themselves without jobs.

The same kinds of changes are occurring today. Jobs are lost dure to technology and global production. But people want their old jobs to continue – which won’t happen. The reality is that cars could be produced via computers long distance away - rather than on assembly lines manned by people. Hence, the pain and disconcerting footing beneath them that so many people are experiencing.

Social media is such a wonderful way to connect people.  But the same media can fan anger over change, creating political unrest. Populism is seen as a solution world-wise. Until it becomes like the clamor of many people shouting in a room, so loud that you can’t hear yourself think. And the uncertainty of living in a world with so many autocratic rulers casts a additional dark shadow over all of us.

When I was young, people did not question whether the news was true or not. As if truth were some kind of objective absolute and verifiable reality. Now intentional fake news confounds our confusion. What do we dare to believe is actually accurate? I am reminded of cattle guards. You can drive into the pasture or range land. But try to back up to gain a wider perspective and your tires will be shredded.

There are many problems confronting us that need solving, making the loss of buggy whips almost laughable. Never forget there are solutions to be created for so much that we face.


There a number of constructive ways to live in all this uncertainty and unpredictability.  My suggestions are to work for constructive political changes. Travel – to other countries. Engage in conversations with people whose cultures differ from yours. Challenge yourself.  Imagine what you cannot possibly imagine.

Monday, November 14, 2016

the days after

brush my teeth
wash a load of clothes
plunge the toilet
check my email
feed the cats
go out for lunch
watch the last leaves fall
wave at the mailman
pay some bills


pray for my country

Monday, August 15, 2016

The Power and Tragedy of Political Assasination

How do people gain perspective when they live in the midst of history being made?

My husband and I moved to Washington DC in 1962. It was a heady place to be living. Live concerts by famous musicians, bookstores, and people from all over the world. The Smithsonian and art galleries. The Library of Congress with two copies of everything ever printed. Congress in session.

The March on Washington on the mall. It was the time of civil rights unrest. Our generation was determined to dramatically change our culture.

In November 1983, helicopters flew over the city announcing that President Kennedy had been shot. By evening it was clear he was dead. Not wanting to go home, we had something to eat at Woodward and Lothrop, a department store with a small restaurant.

Then we joined many others wandering the streets. People were in shell shock. There was little conversation, but like us people sought solace in being with others.

We were standing on Wisconsin Avenue when the motorcade carrying Kennedy’s body rushed by on the way to the Naval Hospital in Bethesda. There he was officially declared dead.

Later we learned that Lyndon Johnson had been sworn in as President as the presidential plane traveled from Dallas to Andrews Air Force base in Arlington. A sniper who disagreed with Kennedy was the assassin.

The next days were a blur. This was not supposed to happen. How did a person make sense of these events? My memories are crystal clear, visual and vivid. But they are a patchwork without any cognitive coherence.

During the transition, Johnson kindly gave Jackie several months to move out of the White House. Every morning Johnson was escorted by motorcade to the West Wing to go to work – traveling fast down Massachusetts Avenue, the avenue of embassies. Past the school where my husband was doing graduate work.

Political assassination is no joking matter. Along with others, we hoped it would never happen again.

But that was not to be. Five years later, Martin Luther King Jr. was killed by a sniper. Months later Bobby Kennedy lay wasted on the ground. Twenty years later I was at a conference, when it was announced that Yitzhak Rabin was assassinated.  A women in the group came forward keening. The sound stays with me.


It only takes one person with a gun to change the course of history.

Saturday, August 6, 2016

A Millennial's Thoughtful Question

Some of our family had gathered around the table to share a meal and catch up with each other’s lives. After awhile, the conversation turned to current events in our community and beyond. Police shootings and police being shot. Black lives under attack. Inequality of rights in this country that has led to protests and sit-ins. Wars raging elsewhere and Europe under attack by ISIS. 

My husband and I reminisced about our involvement in the sixties’ civil rights movement. At a point in the conversation, one of the younger adults asked a ques†ion. He said: our generation of millennials has never known a time like this, but you two lived through tumultuous times when you were our age. How was that time the same and how is it different from today?

Over several days, I reflected on his question. Not necessarily “historically correct” observations, many others have done this analysis - but my perspective and feelings about this significant time in my early adult life. A time when my husband and I left the relative isolation of the rural Midwest to be plunged into what seemed to me like the heady center of the universe of our nation’s capital.

Words that spoke to the tumult of the sixties still speak to us today. Anne Lamott, writes 
in Traveling Mercies:  
When a lot of things start going wrong all at once
it is to protect something big and lovely
that is trying to get itself born--
and that this something needs for us to be distracted
so that it can be born as perfectly as possible.

Lamottcites a Tibetan belief and goes on to say:
That something big and lovely is our future.
It is our time and labor to embrace it,
for out of every death springs new life.

Those years so long ago did feel like something was being born. We believed we could change the world by passing laws against discrimination.

The civil rights movement was not a global issue. It was focused on events in this country. The cold war had been in existence for sometime, but I doubted Europe or Great Britain saw discrimination as their issue or paid much attention to what was going on here. Civil right was a uniquely American issue from the enslavement of African men and women, decades of repression, and the Civil War.

There was no internet telling us often within hours or even minutes of significant events around the world. I can’t even remember how we learned about what happened in Selma, Alabama, even though a close friend was there. There wer no cyber-attacks to worry over.  And no social media, instantly connecting us with individuals halfway round the world
.
Today, problems are global, far more complex, and tangled with so many issues unrelated to civil rights. What happens in France or the Middle East affects us in this country. What happened in Ferguson reverberates everywhere.  What Russia or North Korea do or say impacts  us locally.

Political leaders today are under minute scrutiny. Every word, every twitch is fodder for the news. Personalities are often the focus – over the issues. News is mixed with its entertainment value. Sure, we were fascinated with the Kennedys and Martin Luther King, but not in examining every detail of their daily personal lives – over and over again.

A spirit of optimism was pervasive. We believed we could take action and things would change. And much did. The Voting Rights Bill was passed and signed. As an outgrowth of the protest culture, the women’s movement has given women opportunities they didn’t dream of in the sixties. Where gender roles were rigid for most men and women. Yes, I picketed the White House - with my infant daughter in my arms. But I knew my place was in my home. And the civil rights movement morphed into protesting the war in Vietnam, using the same tactics of marches and protests that were so effective in addressing civil rights.

Fifty years ago, the movement within our culture was not a religious war. It was a moral war. Fear and gloom were not factors that pushed the civil rights movement. It was driven by a sense of justice. There was no distorted version of one world religion being used to justify violence or the determination to take over the world. The Ku Klux Klan was the closest “religion” to today’s ISIS. They were scary people dressed up in those white hoods and roads. But mostly, church leaders took an active role in denouncing racism.

The police were “not the enemy” nor were they victims. Yes, some of them did terrible things in the name of keeping peace. (Remember Selma for example). But they were not targeted for assassination. Today’s shooting would have shocked people even more then than they do today.

I remember being in graduate school at the University, when tear gas began to waft through the open windows. We left the building to see police trotting down the mall wearing gas masks. Had no idea then why - even though the image is crystal clear in my memory. Nor were any of us watching afraid of them.

Guns. The sniper assassination of JFK was unprecedented. It was the day so many of us lost our innocence. The proliferation of guns today has meant daily senseless shootings. From random shootings to deliberate acts to take lives. Not just in this country but in Europe and elsewhere. Europe was the safest place anywhere – is now haunted by the fear of more ISIS attacks.

During the sixties, there was not a yawning gap between those who had from those who did not – unless you were black. Wall Street was not a part of the problem. A household could live comfortably on one income. The middle class was large, and within reach of so many of us. Yes there was poverty, black and white. But our efforts were creation of Head Start and a numbr of other Federal programs. In addition to gradual integration of public schools.
                
Today’s presidential campaign would have been unbelievable in the sixties. Science fiction maybe. But not real time/real life. Sometimes it is hard not to feel hopeless or voiceless. How can one person create change, given the complex intertwined issues? Where even to begin?

Bernie Sanders began a revolution that I doubt even he did not expect would happen. It touched something deep inside people desiring a better society. However, permission has been given to voice unprecedented hatred and bigotry. In the voting booth, we all need to look deep inside and consider what we want the future to be.

A wise man said the following over twenty centuries ago:
Do not be daunted by
the enormity of the world's grief.
Do justly, now. Love mercy, now.
Walk humbly, now.
You are not obligated to complete the work,
but neither are you free to abandon it.
                                 - Rabbi Tarfon


My generation has to come to terms with contributions we made were not the solution to so much discrimination. We did our part, but the work is not done. The young adults of this day need to decide what they can do to further the work.